In a candid and challenging address to the national disability community, Theo W. Braddy, Executive Director of the National Council on Independent Living (NCIL), has urged advocates, organizations, and allies to examine the internal dynamics of their advocacy work. In a message titled “I See It,” Braddy addressed what he describes as a painful paradox within the movement: while advocates fight tirelessly to dismantle societal oppression and exclusion, internal harm, bullying, and division frequently undermine their collective progress.
The address, released by NCIL, highlights the necessity of maintaining the same standards of dignity, respect, and accountability within the disability community that advocates demand from the broader public. Braddy emphasized that passion for social justice and righteous anger regarding systemic injustices do not excuse harmful behavior among colleagues and allies.
I See It: Examining Internal Harm in Advocacy
Braddy’s message centers on a deeply personal and organizational observation of how advocates treat one another. While the disability rights movement has historically stood at the forefront of demanding accountability, equal access, and human rights from external institutions, Braddy pointed out that internal reflection is often neglected.
“There is something that tears a big, gaping hole in the heart of the work we do to advance the rights and improve the lives of people with disabilities,” Braddy stated in his address. “It is the harm we sometimes do to one another.”
He detailed several troubling patterns observed across the advocacy landscape, noting instances where calls for inclusion paradoxically leave marginalized voices behind—including the very individuals whose lives are most directly impacted by organizational decisions. Braddy also highlighted how passionate advocacy can sometimes devolve into bullying, and how legitimate disagreements over tactical approaches are frequently weaponized to attack an individual’s personal character, moral commitment, or overall worth within the movement.
Furthermore, Braddy addressed the alarming tendency of organizations and grassroots advocates to marginalize or outright dismiss long-standing allies simply because they pursue different strategic pathways toward shared objectives. When strategic divergence is misinterpreted as a lack of dedication or compassion, the entire movement suffers.
“We call it holding the line. We call it fighting for what is right. But we need to ask ourselves: Does the way we are fighting reflect the values we say we are fighting for?” Braddy asked, noting that being legally or morally correct on a policy issue does not automatically legitimize harmful behaviors carried out in its name.
Balancing Accountability and Respect
While calling for a cultural shift away from toxicity and division, Braddy was careful to clarify that his message should not be misconstrued as a call to suppress difficult conversations, ignore systemic misconduct, or avoid necessary accountability. Robust debate, rigorous questioning of institutional decisions, and proactive intervention when individuals are harmed remain vital components of effective advocacy.
However, Braddy stressed that these crucial actions can and must be executed without resorting to public humiliation, character assassination, or malicious tearing down of peers. True accountability, he argued, requires a baseline of mutual respect that honors the humanity of every participant in the movement.
In an unprecedented display of personal and organizational leadership, Braddy turned the mirror inward, acknowledging that leaders are not exempt from perpetuating these cycles of harm. He posed a series of critical self-reflection questions for himself and his peers: Have leaders listened as carefully as they demand others listen to them? Have they actively created space for dissenting opinions? Have they demonstrated the humility required to admit when they are wrong?
“I cannot ask others to examine themselves if I am willing to do the same,” Braddy said. He noted that he was not singling out any specific individual or organization, but rather addressing a systemic pattern that requires universal awareness and correction.
Turning Collective Numbers Into Collective Power
According to Braddy, these internal fractures directly impede the broader mission of the disability rights movement. Despite boasting significant numbers, deep institutional experience, and profound collective knowledge, the community often struggles to translate these assets into cohesive, unstoppable political and social power.
A disproportionate amount of vital energy and resources is currently expended on internal conflicts and ideological purity tests, leaving inadequate bandwidth for the foundational policy and civil rights work that originally united the community. Braddy asserted that diversity of thought and strategic disagreement do not require the silencing of dissenting voices or the erosion of basic human dignity.
By taking personal responsibility for interpersonal conduct, the movement can preserve its integrity, foster deeper solidarity, and present a united front in the ongoing fight for disability justice and civil rights across the United States.
About NCIL
Founded in 1982, the National Council on Independent Living stands as the longest-running national cross-disability grassroots organization in the United States. Driven entirely by and dedicated to people with disabilities, NCIL has spent decades representing thousands of organizations and individual advocates. The council continues to lead national advocacy efforts aimed at securing comprehensive human and civil rights, full societal inclusion, and independent living access for individuals with disabilities nationwide.
