In a collaborative new study that sheds light on student safety across the United States, researchers from the Indiana University School of Medicine and the Brain Injury Association of America have discovered that a significant portion of the nation’s K-12 schools lack adequate concussion protocols. Furthermore, the findings reveal that many institutions fail to provide proper staff training for managing the complex recovery process that follows a traumatic brain injury.
The study, which utilized public data collected from educational surveys, was recently published in the Journal of School Nursing. It highlights a growing institutional vulnerability in the way academic environments handle head injuries, placing an immense burden on school nurses who must navigate these delicate recovery phases often with little to no structural support.
A concussion is classified as a form of traumatic brain injury that can be caused by a blow to the head or a violent jolt to the body. While the term is frequently associated with contact sports like football and soccer, concussions can happen anywhere on a school campus—during physical education classes, on the playground, in hallways, or even during routine extracurricular activities.
The symptoms following a concussion can be diverse and deeply disruptive to a student’s daily life. Affected students frequently experience persistent headaches, dizziness, and trouble with concentration, memory, balance, mood, and sleep. Because these symptoms directly affect cognitive functions, returning a student to the classroom after a concussion is an intricate and delicate process that requires careful, individualized support, patience, and professional oversight.
According to the study’s authors, school nurses are standing at the very epicenter of this medical and educational challenge. Kelly Sarmiento, MPH, the director of outreach programs for the Brain Injury Association of America and the corresponding author of the study, emphasized the critical and often overwhelming role that these healthcare professionals play within the K-12 school system.
"School nurses are absolutely central to concussion management in schools, and in many cases, they’re carrying a significant share of that responsibility," Sarmiento explained.
In a typical scenario, a school nurse must act as a central communication hub. They are tasked with coordinating care and recovery strategies among worried families, external healthcare providers, and various school staff members, including teachers, counselors, and administrators, all while continuously monitoring the student’s fluctuating symptoms.
However, the new research indicates that this critical safety net is fraying due to systemic institutional neglect. Sarmiento pointed out that the study’s data reveals a stark disconnect between the reality of student injuries and the preparedness of the schools meant to protect them.
"Our findings show that many nurses may be doing this without the support they need," Sarmiento said. "About one in four schools reported having no concussion policy at all, and even among those that do, fewer than a third require staff training. That puts added pressure on school nurses to fill in the gaps, whether that’s educating colleagues, coordinating care, or ensuring students get the accommodations they need to recover and succeed."
Likely Causes
Understanding why so many educational institutions operate without comprehensive concussion policies requires looking at the broader systemic challenges facing the American public school system. Dana Waltzman, PhD, an associate research professor of physical medicine and rehabilitation at the IU School of Medicine and a co-author of the study, noted that the reasons for these widespread policy holes are varied and deeply complex.
While the study itself did not directly investigate the root causes behind the lack of protocols, Waltzman noted that past research in the field points to a clear set of likely culprits that routinely strain school districts.
"Previous research suggests several possible factors, including limited staffing and resources, lack of access to school health professionals such as full-time nurses or athletic trainers, competing priorities, and challenges implementing policies consistently across schools," Waltzman explained.
Compounding these institutional hurdles, the researchers uncovered troubling disparities in how policies are distributed across different types of communities. The data suggests that systemic inequities play a major role in which schools are equipped to handle student brain injuries safely.
"We also found that schools in higher-poverty communities, schools with larger proportions of non-white students, and smaller schools were less likely to report having concussion policies, which may point to resource and capacity differences," Waltzman added.
To conduct the study, researchers utilized valuable data from the School Pulse Panel, an annual survey filled out by school principals and collected by the National Center for Education Statistics. The collaborative research project was conducted entirely without financial support, relying purely on the dedication of the researchers to bring national attention to an overlooked public health issue within the classroom.
Evidence-Based Guidance
Medical and educational research consistently demonstrates that students recover from concussions far more successfully and rapidly when they are allowed to gradually return to school. Rather than remaining completely isolated at home or being forced to immediately resume a full, unrestricted academic workload, recovering students need tailored classroom support that aligns with their specific symptoms.
Following established, evidence-based guidance helps support neurological recovery while simultaneously minimizing long-term disruptions to a student’s education and social development. Without these structures, students frequently struggle in silence, experiencing declining grades, frustration, and prolonged symptom duration.
In response to their findings, the Brain Injury Association of America is strongly urging schools across the country to adopt standardized, evidence-based practices in handling concussions. Experts emphasize that an ideal institutional response should include a clear delineation of responsibilities, establishing exactly who within the school building is charged with coordinating a student’s medical and academic care. Furthermore, schools should establish clear, flexible return-to-learn timetables for classroom instruction, ensuring that the burden of recovery is shared equitably among trained educators, administrators, and healthcare personnel rather than falling squarely on the shoulders of overworked school nurses.
