Navigating Work Requirements and Medical Exemptions: What SNAP Can Teach Medicaid as New Federal Mandates Approach

As federal policy shifts toward stricter economic participation requirements across major safety-net programs, states are facing mounting administrative hurdles in defining and verifying who should be exempt from these rules. While the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) has long paired food assistance with work requirements, the impending rollout of similar mandates for Medicaid expansion enrollees is forcing state agencies to rethink how they handle exemptions for individuals with physical or mental limitations. With significant financial penalties looming for administrative errors in both programs, policymakers are looking closely at how SNAP has historically managed these challenges—even as they confront fundamental differences in how the two programs operate.

Under existing federal guidelines, SNAP serves as the primary federal aid program addressing food insecurity among low-income households, and it has long included work requirements as a condition of participation for certain individuals. Looking ahead, this framework is expanding dramatically. Starting January 1, 2027, or sooner at the discretion of individual states, 44 states will be required to condition Medicaid eligibility for adults in the Affordable Care Act expansion group, alongside enrollees in certain waiver programs, on meeting strict community engagement and work requirements.

However, federal law explicitly mandates exclusions from these requirements. Most notably, individuals who are deemed "medically frail" are exempt if they possess a qualifying medical condition and can successfully demonstrate that the condition directly impairs their ability to fulfill the mandated work hours. To assist with this transition, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently released information detailing a potential approach that states can utilize to verify medical frailty exclusions. Despite this guidance, states are under no obligation to adopt the federal model, and significant uncertainty remains regarding the exact verification processes individual jurisdictions will ultimately implement.

In light of this widespread uncertainty surrounding Medicaid’s medical frailty verification, policy analysts and state administrators are examining how SNAP has handled similar administrative challenges over the years. Much like the upcoming Medicaid exemption, individuals who are judged unable to work due to a physical or mental limitation are already excused from SNAP work requirements. Yet, the specific methods used by state SNAP agencies to verify a person’s ability to work vary widely. Furthermore, these practices are currently undergoing a period of potential transformation in response to provisions in recent federal reconciliation legislation that require states to shoulder a portion of SNAP benefit costs if their payment error rates exceed specific thresholds. While the mature SNAP program offers valuable insights for the incoming Medicaid requirements, fundamental differences in how each program determines initial eligibility mean that Medicaid’s verification processes will inevitably differ in several critical ways.

How have states historically determined ability to work for the SNAP program?

States have long maintained significant flexibility in how they define the exemption for individuals who are deemed physically or mentally unfit for employment. Under current rules, most adults under the age of 65 receiving SNAP benefits must meet general work requirements. These include registering for work, accepting a suitable job if one is offered, participating in SNAP Employment and Training programs or assigned workfare if directed by the state agency, and avoiding voluntary job quits or arbitrary reductions in work hours below 30 hours per week without a legally recognized "good reason."

Additionally, stricter time-limited work requirements apply to specific individuals who do not qualify for a broad exemption. These participants must work, participate in a work program for at least 80 hours per month, or complete assigned workfare hours in order to receive SNAP benefits for more than three months within a 36-month period.

Federal regulations leave it almost entirely up to state agencies to define physical and mental fitness and to establish their own procedures for verifying general work requirement exemptions. Rules governing time-limited work requirements are only slightly more prescriptive, clarifying that an individual is exempt if they are physically or mentally unfit for employment. Because of this broad federal discretion, formal definitions vary significantly across state lines. Some states have adopted notably expansive definitions of physical or mental limitations, choosing to include populations such as chronically homeless individuals or survivors of domestic violence whose traumatic circumstances severely impact their physical or mental health. Furthermore, states are federally mandated to exempt individuals who receive any form of temporary or permanent disability benefits, including Supplemental Security Income, Worker’s Compensation, Veterans Affairs benefits, Railroad Retirement, or developmental disability services, though they retain discretion over how this documentation is collected and filed.

A mandatory component of the SNAP application and recertification process is a phone or in-person interview conducted by an eligibility worker who screens enrollees for potential exemptions. As of 2023, the majority of states report screening for physical or mental limitations right at the initial application stage, while others introduce these questions during the mandatory interview. More than half of state agencies also reported allowing their frontline staff considerable discretion over the types of physical or mental limitations that could be considered valid for an exemption. For example, direct visual observations made by eligibility workers during an interview, such as noticing that an applicant relies on an oxygen tank, can serve as an immediate basis for granting an exemption.

Assessing Ability to Work: How Historical SNAP Processes May Vary from Medicaid

When determining whether someone is obviously unfit for employment, some state agencies routinely require formal medical documentation of an individual’s limitations, whereas many others readily accept client statements or only demand third-party verification when an eligibility worker deems the situation questionable or unclear. States that do not enforce a blanket documentation rule often specify that unverified client statements are acceptable unless something in the narrative triggers suspicion. An evaluation of SNAP work requirement exemption processes revealed that some eligibility workers favored strict documentation rules because they reduced staff burden and personal liability, fostering greater consistency and lowering the subjectivity of individual determinations. However, regularly requiring formal paperwork inevitably increases the administrative burden for vulnerable enrollees, already stretched healthcare providers, and the caseworkers tasked with processing the files. Because SNAP participants are reevaluated for exemptions during recertification cycles every six to twelve months, studies have found that the information collected at renewal rarely differs from what was gathered during the original application.

When a participant’s unfitness to work is not immediately obvious to an eligibility worker, states are required to obtain a statement from a licensed medical professional to verify exemption status, though local procedures for securing these provider attestations vary widely. Some states go a step further, making provider documentation mandatory for every single person seeking an exemption. The specific information requested from medical professionals to substantiate an exemption also differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. States may accept various forms of provider paperwork, ranging from comprehensive state-designed medical forms to simple written statements or brief phone calls placed directly to an eligibility worker. Because medical providers are rarely given detailed, standardized guidance about how to clinically assess fitness for work, their determinations regarding who qualifies for an exemption inherently vary.

Compounding these operational challenges, states may soon choose to overhaul their SNAP verification workflows in response to a new federal mandate requiring most states to cover a portion of SNAP benefit costs if their payment error rates exceed six percent. Scheduled to take effect in October 2027, this reconciliation law targets over- and underpayments that are primarily administrative errors rather than outright fraud, with the state’s financial share scaling upward as error rates climb. Historically, state SNAP verification policies reflected a delicate balancing act between promoting program integrity and avoiding fiscal penalties against the heavy administrative burdens placed on applicants. Now, with massive financial penalties tied directly to payment error rates, states are actively reevaluating that balance. For instance, to avoid clerical errors and subsequent fiscal penalties, Arizona recently instituted new rules requiring additional documentation for information that the state previously accepted via simple client statements.

How may the Medicaid process compare to SNAP?

In stark contrast to the traditional SNAP process, the upcoming Medicaid pathway for verifying individuals who qualify for the medical frailty exclusion will require states to exhaust all available administrative data before directly requesting documentation from individuals or medical providers. Medicaid programs possess robust access to historical claims and encounter data that SNAP agencies generally do not share. An interim final rule released by federal authorities instructs states to review claims and encounter data from the preceding 12 months in an attempt to automatically verify a beneficiary’s medical frailty status prior to reaching out to the individual.

CMS subsequently outlined a tiered medical frailty framework designed to help states navigate this data landscape. Under this model, states can identify medically frail individuals using claims data alone in the first tier, combine claims with encounter or other administrative data in the second tier, or resort to an individualized manual process requiring supplemental documentation in the third tier when existing data is entirely absent or insufficient. While this tiered approach will successfully automate verification for a substantial portion of the population, data limitations will inevitably persist. Issues such as a complete lack of historical data for newly enrolled applicants, or providers failing to consistently code specific health conditions using state-mandated diagnostic codes, mean that manual verification and outside documentation will remain necessary for many.

Where available data falls short, Medicaid programs will find themselves relying heavily on medical providers to verify a patient’s functional ability to work and their medical frailty status, mirroring aspects of the SNAP model. Because the traditional Medicaid application structure generally does not feature the same kind of structured administrative interviews used in SNAP, eligibility caseworkers will play a much less prominent role in the initial screening process. However, in states where SNAP and Medicaid programs are jointly administered, or where robust data-sharing agreements exist, Medicaid agencies may be able to leverage information already gathered through SNAP interviews.

When automated data systems cannot confirm medical frailty, states must depend on treating physicians and clinicians to attest to qualifying conditions and evaluate an individual’s capacity to participate in community engagement activities. Because the current interim final rule offers very little granular detail regarding the exact data points states must collect from providers, individual jurisdictions are expected to develop their own disparate forms, mirroring the historical fragmentation seen in SNAP. Some states are already exploring unified approaches; for example, North Carolina has designed a single provider attestation form that can be utilized to determine eligibility exemptions across both Medicaid and SNAP programs. Nonetheless, relying on clinicians to assess work capacity without standardized guidelines risks introducing the same inconsistencies that have long challenged the food assistance program.

Furthermore, beginning in January 2028, states’ ability to accept self-attestation within the Medicaid program will become significantly more restrictive than current SNAP standards. While SNAP rules require states to seek further verification only when self-reported information appears questionable, federal policy does not place a blanket ban on client statements. In contrast, the new Medicaid rule establishes a strict timeline that curtails reliance on self-attestation. States will be permitted to accept self-attestation throughout 2027 in instances where no reliable electronic data is available. However, starting January 1, 2028, a state may only accept self-attestation of medical frailty status a single time during an individual’s enrollment span. For subsequent renewals, states will be forced to rely entirely on automated data or demand direct documentation from the enrollee or their provider, substantially increasing administrative friction. Prior to the publication of these federal rules, a majority of states had signaled a strong preference for utilizing self-attestation to streamline the medical frailty exemption process.

Ultimately, state-level Medicaid medical frailty verification policies are expected to diverge sharply, with local decisions heavily influenced by the looming threat of federal financial penalties. Operating under sparse federal guidance, state agencies must design compliance structures that protect them from fiscal sanctions while avoiding excessive administrative burdens that could wrongfully strip healthcare coverage from vulnerable residents. Complicating matters further, states must implement these complex policy changes simultaneously as they prepare for sweeping updates to the Medicaid Payment Error Rate Measurement program. These concurrent regulatory shifts will increase the financial stakes of eligibility error rates exceeding three percent, forcing state administrators to constantly weigh fiscal risk against the human cost of mandatory paperwork as the 2027 implementation deadlines draw closer.

Azzam Bilal Chamdy

Penulis aktif di HypePress yang membagikan konten inspiratif, informasi terkini, dan gaya hidup untuk generasi muda.

Artikel Bermanfaat dan Menghibur Lainnya