Navigating Work Requirements and Medical Exemptions: What SNAP Can Teach Medicaid as New Federal Rules Approach

As federal policy shifts toward stricter community engagement and work mandates across major safety-net programs, state administrators are facing complex administrative challenges in verifying who should be exempt due to physical or mental limitations. While the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) has long managed work requirements alongside exemptions for individuals deemed unfit for employment, upcoming federal mandates will soon introduce similar requirements to the Medicaid program. Starting January 1, 2027—or sooner at the option of individual states—44 states will be required to condition Medicaid eligibility for adults in the Affordable Care Act expansion group, as well as enrollees in certain waiver programs, on meeting work requirements.

However, federal law includes mandatory exclusions from these mandates, most notably for individuals classified as "medically frail." To qualify for this specific medical frailty exemption, an enrollee must have a qualifying medical condition and successfully demonstrate that the condition directly impairs their ability to fulfill the mandated work requirements. Recently, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released guidance outlining a proposed framework that states can utilize to verify medical frailty exclusions. Despite this federal guidance, states are not explicitly required to adopt the proposed approach, leaving considerable uncertainty regarding the exact administrative processes states will ultimately implement.

Given this looming uncertainty over how state agencies will handle Medicaid medical frailty verifications, examining how SNAP has historically navigated similar administrative hurdles provides valuable context. Much like the forthcoming Medicaid exemption, individuals who are found unable to work because of physical or mental limitations are shielded from SNAP work mandates. Yet, the approaches utilized by state SNAP agencies to verify an individual’s ability to work vary widely. Furthermore, these practices are currently undergoing potential shifts in response to provisions within recent reconciliation legislation. This legislation requires states to absorb a portion of SNAP benefit costs if their payment error rates exceed specific thresholds, prompting some states to reevaluate their verification strictness. While insights from SNAP can help inform Medicaid implementation, fundamental differences in how each program determines eligibility mean that Medicaid verification processes will ultimately diverge from SNAP in several critical ways.

How Have States Historically Determined Ability to Work for the SNAP Program?

States have long retained considerable flexibility in how they define the exemption for individuals deemed "physically or mentally unfit for employment." Under federal guidelines, most SNAP adults under the age of 65 must comply with general work requirements. These baseline rules include registering for employment, accepting a suitable job if one is offered, participating in assigned SNAP Employment and Training or workfare programs, and avoiding voluntary job quits or arbitrary reductions in work hours below 30 hours per week without a recognized good cause. Additionally, time-limited work requirements apply strictly to non-exempt adults, mandating that they work or participate in a work program for at least 80 hours per month—or fulfill designated workfare hours—to maintain SNAP benefits for more than three months within a rolling 36-month period.

Federal regulations deliberately leave it to individual state agencies to define physical and mental fitness and establish localized procedures for verifying exemptions from general work requirements. Rules concerning time-limited work requirements offer only slightly more specific parameters, clarifying simply when an individual is exempt from those specific temporal limits. Because of this broad federal discretion, formal definitions vary significantly across state lines. Several states utilize expansive interpretations of physical or mental limitations, choosing to include vulnerable populations such as chronically homeless individuals or survivors of domestic violence whose traumatic experiences severely impact their daily physical or mental functioning. Furthermore, states are federally mandated to exempt individuals who receive any form of temporary or permanent disability benefits, including Supplemental Security Income, Workers’ Compensation, Veterans Affairs benefits, Railroad Retirement, or developmental disability services, though states continue to vary significantly in how they document and verify these statuses.

A mandatory component of the standard SNAP application and recertification process is a direct phone or in-person interview with an eligibility worker who screens enrollees for potential exemptions. Reporting data indicates that most states prioritize screening for physical or mental limitations during the initial application phase, while others prefer to explore potential limitations during the mandatory interview conducted prior to final program certification. More than half of state agencies have also reported granting frontline staff considerable discretion over the types of physical or mental limitations that can warrant an exemption. For instance, visual observations made directly by eligibility workers during certification interviews—such as noticing that an applicant relies on an oxygen tank—can serve as an acceptable foundational basis for granting an exemption.

When determining whether someone is obviously unfit for employment, state practices diverge sharply. Some jurisdictions consistently require formal medical documentation of an individual’s limitations, whereas many others readily accept client statements or only demand verification when an eligibility worker explicitly deems the situation questionable or unclear. Evaluations of SNAP work requirement exemption protocols reveal that some eligibility workers appreciate mandatory documentation policies because they reduce personal administrative burden and subjectivity by establishing clear, consistent standards. However, enforcing rigid documentation requirements inevitably increases administrative friction for vulnerable enrollees, healthcare providers, and caseworkers alike, who must process the paperwork and frequently request supplementary clarifications. Because individuals must be reevaluated for work exemptions during routine recertifications every six to twelve months, administrative systems frequently process the same baseline information repeatedly without significant changes.

Assessing Ability to Work: How Historical SNAP Processes May Vary from Medicaid

When unfitness to work is not immediately obvious to an intake worker, states are required to obtain a formal statement from a licensed medical professional to verify exemption status, though internal state procedures for collecting these provider attestations vary widely. Some states enforce a blanket policy requiring provider documentation for every single individual seeking a medical exemption. The specific information requested from healthcare providers to substantiate an exemption also lacks uniformity across jurisdictions. States may accept written statements, standardized medical forms, or even direct phone attestations from treating clinicians. Because medical providers typically receive little to no detailed guidance regarding how to assess occupational fitness for public assistance programs, their determinations regarding who qualifies for an exemption inherently vary.

Compounding these operational choices, states are now reevaluating their SNAP verification frameworks in response to new federal financial pressures. A mandate within recent reconciliation legislation requires most states to pay a portion of overall SNAP benefit costs if their payment error rate—a metric capturing administrative overpayments and underpayments rather than deliberate fraud—rises above 6 percent. As error rates climb past this threshold, the state’s financial liability increases up to a predetermined cap. Historically, state verification policies balanced the need for program integrity against the administrative burdens placed on applicants. However, with substantial fiscal penalties now tied directly to payment error rates, states are shifting their calculations. For instance, in an effort to minimize administrative errors and avoid steep financial sanctions, Arizona recently implemented stricter documentation rules for information that caseworkers previously accepted via simple client statements unless flagged as questionable.

How May the Medicaid Process Compare to SNAP?

In stark contrast to the historical SNAP verification process, the upcoming Medicaid framework for identifying individuals who qualify for the medical frailty exclusion will obligate states to exhaust all available administrative data before directly requesting documentation from enrollees or their healthcare providers. Unlike SNAP agencies, Medicaid programs maintain comprehensive repositories of healthcare claims and encounter data. An interim final rule released by federal regulators instructs states to systematically utilize claims and encounter data from the preceding 12 months to attempt automatic verification of medical frailty status before burdening the individual with information requests.

CMS has outlined a tiered medical frailty framework designed to facilitate this data-driven approach. Under this structure, states can identify medically frail enrollees using claims data alone in the first tier, combine claims with encounter or alternative administrative data in the second tier, or resort to an individualized manual process requiring additional documentation in the third tier where data is absent or insufficient. While this tiered model will successfully automate verifications for many, data limitations—such as a complete lack of historical data for newly enrolled applicants or instances where treating physicians fail to code chronic conditions consistently using state-designated billing codes—mean that manual documentation will remain necessary for a substantial subset of enrollees.

When available administrative data proves insufficient, Medicaid will mirror SNAP by relying heavily on treating medical providers to verify an individual’s ability to work and their underlying medical frailty status. Because the Medicaid program generally does not utilize intake interviews, frontline eligibility workers will play a less pronounced role in the verification pathway compared to SNAP. Nevertheless, in states where SNAP and Medicaid programs are jointly administered or share integrated data systems, Medicaid agencies may leverage information initially gathered during SNAP certification interviews. In situations where automated data matches fail, states must depend on clinical confirmations from treating providers to substantiate medical frailty and evaluate an individual’s capacity to participate in community engagement activities. Because current federal rules offer minimal detail regarding the precise information states must collect from providers, individual states are expected to develop divergent forms and requirements, echoing the fragmented landscape seen in SNAP. Some states may even attempt to streamline the process by utilizing combined provider attestation forms that satisfy both Medicaid and SNAP exemption criteria, as seen in North Carolina. However, relying on clinicians to make occupational assessments without standardized guidelines risks introducing similar inconsistencies and subjective variations.

Furthermore, beginning in January 2028, state flexibility to accept self-attestation within the Medicaid program will be significantly more constrained than historical practices allowed under SNAP. While SNAP rules require states to seek further verification only when client statements appear questionable without placing a blanket federal cap on self-attestation, the Medicaid regulations impose strict temporal limits on unverified self-reports. States are permitted to accept self-attestation of medical frailty throughout calendar year 2027 when reliable electronic data is unavailable. However, starting January 1, 2028, states may only accept self-attestation of medical frailty a single time during an enrollee’s continuous enrollment period. For subsequent renewals, states will be required to verify frailty through automated data sources or demand formal clinical documentation from the individual, initiating a more rigorous and time-consuming administrative review. Prior to the formal publication of the interim federal rules, a majority of states had expressed strong interest in utilizing self-attestation as a primary verification method for the medical frailty exemption.

Ultimately, state Medicaid verification policies are expected to diverge significantly, heavily influenced by the looming threat of federal financial penalties. Operating with limited federal standardization, state administrators must independently design operational workflows for the medical frailty exclusion. Federal regulations make clear that states will face noncompliance penalties if post-payment audits reveal frequent approvals of medical frailty exemptions without robust supporting evidence demonstrating how the condition genuinely impairs an individual’s ability to work. Balancing the imperative to protect the state treasury from financial penalties against the goal of minimizing administrative barriers—all while ensuring eligible vulnerable residents do not lose healthcare coverage—presents a formidable operational challenge. These complex Medicaid policy changes are unfolding simultaneously as states prepare for sweeping adjustments to the Medicaid Payment Error Rate Measurement program, which will heighten the fiscal consequences associated with eligibility error rates exceeding 3 percent. These converging financial pressures will undoubtedly shape how state leaders calibrate their verification policies across both safety-net programs in the years ahead.

Azzam Bilal Chamdy

Penulis aktif di HypePress yang membagikan konten inspiratif, informasi terkini, dan gaya hidup untuk generasi muda.

Artikel Bermanfaat dan Menghibur Lainnya